$548,000 - 31 Stuart Avenue, St. Catharines
Multi-Family for Sale in St. Catharines
Neighbourhood: 451 - Downtown
Want to see this home in person?
Book a private showing with Joe — pick a day and time that works for you.
- MLS Number
- X13752872
- Property Type
- Multi-Family
- Status
- active
- Days on Site
- 29
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Square Feet
- 1,100 - 1,499 sqft
- Neighbourhood
- St. Catharines
- Taxes (2026)
- $3,740
- Listing Brokerage
- RIGHT AT HOME REALTY, BROKERAGE
Lovely character home with great curb appeal and full of charm located in the coveted Fitzgerald area of downtown St.Catharines. Welcome to 31 Stuart Avenue a wonderful long time family owned home that features a two bedroom apartment on the main floor and a large bright one bedroom apartment up! Basement is unfinished and has been waterproofed from the inside. This would be an excellent multi generational opportunity! As you enter the ground floor you will find a comfortable living room with a bay window allowing lots of natural light and a cozy fireplace. A nice sized dining area leads to a working kitchen, there are two bedrooms on this level both with fantastic corner windows with views of the generous backyard. A four piece bath completes this level. The second level boasts a bright spacious one bedroom apartment which is accessed from a separate entrance at the rear of the home. The lot is 40X120 and features a one car garage and a concrete driveway. Upgrades over the years include most newer vinyl windows and a metal long life roof(Hindrea Roofing 2018). Located within walking distance to Harriet Tubman or St.Denis Elementary schools and for secondary St.Catharines Collegiate or St.Francis Secondary the later would qualify for bus transportation. Close to all other amenities including shopping, churches and fine dining you will love the convenience of this downtown location. Be sure to check out the local website for details on community events and more info about the FITZ at fitzgeraldneighbours.ca. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own this lovely home, call your Realtor today!
Estimate your monthly payments for this property
Estimated Payment
$2,811.52/mo
Includes CMHC insurance ($15,289)
5-yr fixed avg.
Rates shown are estimates based on typical Ontario 5-year fixed rates. Canadian mortgages use semi-annual compounding as required by law. CMHC insurance applies to purchases under $1.5M with less than 20% down. Estimated property tax uses an approximate 0.85% rate. Contact us for current rate options and pre-approval.
Discover 451 - Downtown
451 - Downtown is a vibrant community in the Greater Toronto Area, offering excellent amenities, schools, and transportation options. This area is popular with families and professionals seeking a balanced lifestyle with access to urban conveniences and natural spaces.
Why Live in 451 - Downtown
- •Convenient location in St. Catharines
- •Access to local shops and dining
- •Good public transit connections
- •Community parks and green spaces
- •Well-maintained neighbourhoods
Nearby Schools
Transit & Commuting
- •MiWay bus routes throughout the area
- •GO Transit stations within driving distance
- •Easy highway access to 401/403/QEW
- •Walking distance to local amenities
Parks & Amenities
- •Local parks and recreational facilities
- •Community centres
- •Shopping plazas nearby
- •Restaurants and cafes
Lifestyle & Community
451 - Downtown offers a wonderful quality of life with a mix of residential charm and urban convenience. Residents enjoy easy access to schools, parks, and shopping, making it an ideal location for families and professionals alike.
31 Stuart Avenue, St. Catharines
Open in Google MapsUse the map controls to zoom, pan, and switch between map and satellite views. Drag to explore the neighbourhood.
Rental income estimator & ROI calculator
Monthly Cash Flow Breakdown
Note: These are estimates only. Actual figures may vary based on market conditions, property condition, and other factors. Consult with a financial advisor for personalized advice.
Joe's Thoughts
Honest perspective from 30+ years of GTA real estate experience
Competitive Pricing
At $498/sqft, this is priced below the area average. This could represent genuine value, but let's investigate why. In my experience, underpriced homes often have deferred maintenance, unfavourable layouts, or motivated sellers. I'll help you determine which it is.
Market Position
At 29 days on site, this property has had reasonable exposure. It hasn't sold immediately (which often indicates overpricing), but isn't languishing either. There's likely room for a 3-5% negotiation from asking price.
Starter Home Potential
3 bedrooms works well for couples planning families or small families with one child. Consider whether you might outgrow the space in 5-7 years. If so, factor in potential moving costs when making your decision. Alternatively, some buyers convert a bedroom to an office and make it work long-term.
About 451 - Downtown
I know 451 - Downtown well from working with many buyers and sellers here. Each pocket has its own character - let me share what I've learned about this specific street and block. During our showing, I'll point out local amenities, school catchments, and what similar homes have sold for recently.
Investment Perspective
Looking at this as an investment: St. Catharines properties have averaged 5-7% annual appreciation over the past decade. Your estimated monthly carrying costs would be around $2,283 (mortgage, taxes, insurance). Consider whether you're comfortable with this as both a home and a financial commitment.
Let's See It Together
Photos only tell part of the story. During our showing, I'll point out things the camera doesn't capture: neighbourhood feel, natural light quality, traffic noise, and overall condition. I'll also share what comparable homes have sold for and help you craft a winning strategy if you decide to move forward.